It’s India… not Hindia!

The Narendra Modi government’s recent hustle with Tamil Nadu government over the supposed imposition of Hindi language is something that had been raising concerns in social media. Under these circumstances, when debates are doing the rounds, about India and its languages, I’d like to ask a question. Do Indians need to speak one language to understand one another?

We have been one nation for over sixty years with multiple languages spoken across several states; languages belonging to different families – Dravidian, Indo-Aryan, Tibeto-Burman…
And, English, the colonizer’s language serves as the second official language. Most of the urban class is able to speak English, in varying fluency levels. Why can’t we just go on like we did for the past six decades?


My next question is quite simple and is aroused out of mere curiosity. Why Hindi? I have been looking everywhere for some valid reason to believe that Hindi can be that one language that is needed to bring the nation into some sort of convoluted togetherness. No one has been able to suggest a reason as to why Hindi is being chosen as the language the rest of the country should be learning. Is it linguistically better than other languages? Does it possess some distinct cultural traits that change the social status of the speaker? Or is it because it is believed to be spoken by the heartland of India? Newspaper articles and television debates fail to answer any of those questions that I have in mind.

Some people have a problem with me when I say that Hindi, as a language was imposed on me. I have never really realised why I should learn Hindi. It was forced on me when I was halfway through my schooling. One fine morning in the beginning of a school year demanded that I learn Hindi; along with Malayalam (my mother tongue) and English (the medium in which everything was taught). I felt stupid. More than that I felt angry. I was made to read and write a language that I had nothing to do with; a language that was of no use to me. At the end of that five year forced-learning of that language, I was able to read and write Hindi better than more than half of the native speakers of it. But when it comes to speaking, I would prefer acting like a dumb person.

When the Hyderabad stage of my life started, I was expected to pick up Hindi. With so many speakers of Hindi around, I was sure I will learn it. But my own stubbornness and the stubbornness of the Hindi-speakers to expect everyone else to speak Hindi, made me ignore it. All the girlfriends I have (had) were excellent speakers of Hindi and even that factor did not make it any important to me.

Some say Hindi is an easy language to learn. Is it? What if I argue that Tamil/Malayalam can be learned easily too. Why not try and teach some North Indians a bit of Tamil or Telugu? Why not put some young Hindi speaking kids through the ordeal of learning Malayalam letters, starting from their fifth standard? How about a including an option between Kannada and Telugu in North Indian curriculum?

Does learning Hindi makes me a better Indian? The idea of India itself is of a region where several cultures and languages cohabitate. Just because less that 10% of Hindi-speaking politicians had a loose motion does not mean that India and its non-Hindi speakers should ready their toilets. Native speakers of Hindi can continue to speak their language and keep on expecting others to speak it. People like me don’t give a damn.


About these ads

6 thoughts on “It’s India… not Hindia!

  1. A little disappointed after reading this post. I hate this north south divide battle. Battle of languages or battles of egos…I think it is the latter. I have been in chennai for two years without knowing the language. Yes at times I m expected to know the language and twice was told what are u doin in TN if u don’t know Tamil. I brush it off coz I m an Indian and am not interested in the battle of egos..I agree that any one South Indian language shd b taught in North India too..i But I equally agree that Hindi shd be taught in South india too..why? Coz I feel it will bring all of us closer. I don’t like the idea of conversing with my fellow Indians in an international limits our expressions..I so wish that at least our generation looks past these ego barriers and look at the bigger picture ..a unified india. Happy evolving!!


    1. Baldeep,
      I understand it may look like a battle of egos. I assure you the intention wasn’t. The post surely did not stem from my ego as a non-Hindi speaker. It is purely an emotional expression as what I had gone through with my experiences with Hindi. The purpose was to say that India does not need a ‘common language’ NOW as we have come through all our history without it. In my opinion, bringing any language to THAT level NOW will only enrage the rest of the India to take up arms against THAT language whether it is Hindi or any other language. I’m quite sure you have faced really stupid questions when you live in TN and do not speak their language. Tamils can be a little persistent when it comes to Language.
      Besides, English was systematically introduced in India. Yes, it was the colonizer’s language but it was something we Indians adapted to. It was introduced over a period of 200 years and the majority of us did not feel it was an imposition unless we were told so. But, the kind of change that this government is talking about is unscientific and unnatural.
      Besides, I believe that more than half of India learning a language that only 20% of the population speaks is something beyond comprehension.


  2. Thought-provoking post, Manu.

    One of my friends asked me if I was one of ‘those anti-Hindi Tamilians’ (an unfortunate(to me, at least) stereotype), just because I don’t usually speak in Hindi. I’m also an ‘elitist’ for preferring to speak in English. (I believe that English is a common language that most of us understand, as I sometimes have difficulties with even other dialects of Tamil) I remember speaking to friends in Telugu during college, but not in Hindi, but then, that’s mainly because I speak a more textbook Hindi, and a lot of common expressions and slang gets lost on me.

    At the end of the day, I think it’s up to you to use a language you’re comfortable with, and so long as you can get your point across, it’s fine.


  3. Kudos for writing this post Manu! A perfect one at that. Just because some (read few) politicians do not know how to read or write or speak in Hindi, it should not be imposed on the remaining 1.23 billion Indians. I have been brought up in the National Capital Territory, and I can fluently read, write and speak Hindi. But I would still not be party to something that is imposed for no good reason.


Leave a Petal in the Basket

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s